This is only a preview of the December 2026 issue of Silicon Chip. You can view 37 of the 104 pages in the full issue, including the advertisments. For full access, purchase the issue for $10.00 or subscribe for access to the latest issues. Articles in this series:
Items relevant to "Advanced Cable Analyser":
Items relevant to "Inrush Current Limiter":
Articles in this series:
Items relevant to "NeoPixel RGB LED Analog Clock, Part 2":
Items relevant to "The Magic Candle":
Purchase a printed copy of this issue for $15.00. |
MARKET CENTRE
Advertise your product or services here in Silicon Chip
FOR SALE
FOR SALE
PCB PRODUCTION
LEDsales
Tronixlabs
PCB MANUFACTURE: single to multilayer. Bare board tested. One-offs to
any quantity. 48 hour service. Artwork
design. Excellent prices. Check out our
specials: www.ldelectronics.com.au
LEDS, BRAND NAME AND GENERIC
LEDs, filament LEDs, LED drivers,
heatsinks, power supplies, kits and
modules, components, breadboards,
hardware, magnets. Please visit www.
ledsales.com.au
WE’RE BACK – AND WE’VE
BROUGHT THE KITS!
Discover something new at the
Tronixlabs store. Explore our growing
range of Australian electronics kits,
learning resources and more for curious
beginners and seasoned enthusiasts
alike. Visit tronixlabs.com to find
your next project and sign up for our
informative newsletter.
Or for more information by post, write
to PO Box 87, Laidley QLD 4341.
KIT ASSEMBLY & REPAIR
KEITH RIPPON KIT ASSEMBLY &
REPAIR:
* Australia & New Zealand;
* Small production runs.
Phone Keith: 0409 662 794
keith.rippon<at>gmail.com
Advertising in Market Centre
PMD WAY offers (almost) everything
for the electronics enthusiast – with
full warranty, technical support and free
delivery worldwide. Visit pmdway.com
to get started.
anyway. Perhaps the 7.5hp rating of
the VSD you bought was ‘overly generous’.
Is the BF469 really
discontinued?
I’ve been a Silicon Chip reader for
many years and have particularly
enjoyed the audio projects, completing many since building your LM1875based amplifier in the 1990s.
One project I especially enjoyed was
the Hummingbird amplifier (December
2021, siliconchip.au/Article/15126).
When I first read that the BF469 transistor was becoming difficult to obtain,
I ordered some from a local supplier
that still had Philips stock.
After reading the recent Calliope
article (April 2026; siliconchip.au/
Article/20084) and its discussion of
the difficulty in sourcing a suitable
VAS transistor, I was surprised to find
that the BF469 was still available. I
then checked my Hummingbird modules more closely and discovered that
the BF469s I had fitted were not Philips
devices at all, but CDIL parts.
siliconchip.com.au
Classified Ad Rates: $32.00 for up to 20 words (punctuation not charged) plus $1.20 for
each additional word. Display ads in Market Centre start at $82.50 per column centimetre
per insertion. All prices include GST.
Closing date: 5 weeks prior to month of sale. To book, email the text to silicon<at>siliconchip.
com.au and include your name, address & credit card details, or phone (02) 9939 3295.
CDIL still appears to manufacture
the BF469, and its datasheet closely
resembles the Philips specifications.
Other manufacturers have also produced versions of the device.
There is plenty of discussion online
suggesting that CDIL BF469s are inferior to the Philips parts, but I have been
unable to find any useful side-by-side
measurements. The specifications for
both devices are remarkably similar,
and the CDIL part is listed as a drop-in
replacement.
The question seems increasingly
relevant as older semiconductor types
disappear or are quietly revised. I
recently encountered a similar situation with NE5532s, as you described
in the August 2026 issue. I rejected a
number of devices that measured on
par with Chinese counterfeits, only
to discover that they were genuine
TI parts!
I’m curious about how much importance should be attached to the manufacturer when a transistor carries the
same type number and the published
datasheets appear to specify essentially the same device.
Australia's electronics magazine
Substituting devices is nothing new,
and the Calliope article itself demonstrates how successfully this can be
done, but it leaves those of us without a distortion analyser or the expertise wondering whether an apparently
suitable substitute (or revision for that
matter!) still performs as it should.
More generally, how should a hobbyist approach this sort of problem?
Alas, can a CDIL BF469 therefore
reasonably be regarded as equivalent
to the original Philips device, or are
there manufacturer-specific differences significant enough to matter in
circuits such as the Hummingbird? (W.
J., Adelaide, SA)
● CDIL is a legitimate Indian semiconductor fabrication company that
has been in business since the 1960s.
However, there are some reasons that
we wouldn’t continue to specify the
BF469 if they are the sole supplier.
The short version is that often,
parts made by other manufacturers
are close enough to the originals to
be substituted in their stead, but it
isn’t always the case, so you have to
be a bit careful.
December 2026 103
|