This is only a preview of the June 2025 issue of Silicon Chip. You can view 42 of the 104 pages in the full issue, including the advertisments. For full access, purchase the issue for $10.00 or subscribe for access to the latest issues. Items relevant to "Hot Water System Solar Diverter, part one":
Items relevant to "SSB Shortwave Receiver, part 1":
Items relevant to "DIY 433MHz Receiver Module":
Articles in this series:
Purchase a printed copy of this issue for $13.00. |
M
easy-to-build
Outdoor Subwoofer
By Julian Edgar
any people have outside speakers
in a deck or patio area, but they
are often small, wall-mounted designs
that lack adequate bass response. This
subwoofer project can add a lot of that
missing bass. Because it’s built around
a fibre cement stool available from
Bunnings, very little woodworking is
needed, and the enclosure is weather
resistant.
This design includes a simple and
cheap protection mechanism that
makes the subwoofer very hard to blow
up (that’s always a danger with small
subwoofers). Depending on your interior décor, it can also be used inside.
The enclosure
The subwoofer enclosure is based
on an elegant white cement stool available from Bunnings, called the “Marquee 350 × 350 × 450mm Stool Side
Sorrento” (I/N 0596376). It costs $69
and, while completely hollow, still
weighs a little under 14kg. You don’t
need to modify it; you simply glue
an internal panel into it and add feet.
Fibre cement is a good material for
speaker enclosures, as it is acoustically
dead (it doesn’t ‘ring’ when tapped)
and is quite stiff. This stool is even
stiffer than most because it uses a
ribbed wall design. The fibre cement
can be painted any colour you want.
If you wish to make the subwoofer
using another design of stool, or even
(gasp!) from MDF or similar, the key
dimension is that a volume behind the
drivers of about 18L is required.
The drivers
This passive subwoofer is designed to be used on an outside deck
or patio. It is quick and easy to build, and will add substantial
bottom-end to your small exterior wall speakers. It’s also largely
weatherproof.
»
»
»
»
»
»
»
»
»
»
74
Excellent frequency response for its size
Inbuilt protection against being over-driven
Medium-power design suitable for amplifiers up to 100W
Uses low-cost drivers
Easy and quick construction
Largely weatherproof, suitable for undercover outdoor use
Can also be used indoors
Can be painted any colour to match décor
Frequency response: 35-200Hz
Impedance: 4Ω
Silicon Chip
Australia's electronics magazine
Two drivers are used, mounted in
an isobaric (face-to-face) configuration. Both are 170mm (6.5-inch) WS
17 E units made by Visaton. Note that
you need the 8W versions.
These speakers are available worldwide – a web search will find your
nearest stockist. We bought ours from
RS Components (Stock No 431-8563),
but they ended up coming from the
UK. A major criterion in their selection is that they are cheap – about $47
each, including GST.
The speakers come with full ThieleSmall specifications, allowing computer modelling of the enclosure. Still,
when bench tested with the Smith and
Larsen Woofer Tester hardware/software package, the tested specs of the
two drivers differed somewhat from
the official specifications, even after
being ‘run in’.
siliconchip.com.au
Table 1 shows the advertised specifications, the test results and the final
values used in the modelling. Note
that the stated maximum cone displacement is 13mm – something we’ll
come back to later.
Enclosure modelling
Three different designs were modelled using the freely available WinISD speaker enclosure design software.
These designs were sealed, ported and
a 4th-order band-pass configuration.
Fig.1 shows the modelled response
curves of each design approach.
The aim was to achieve a response
from about 150Hz down to 40Hz.
Good efficiency was also important –
that is, the greatest output for a given
power. Given that the bare driver
has a fairly low efficiency (85dB at
1W/1m), achieving maximum efficiency becomes an important part of
the enclosure design.
Of the three designs, the sealed
approach was the worst in efficiency
and had a lower -3dB point of about
43Hz.
The band-pass design had a much
higher efficiency, about 4.5dB louder
in the critical area, so the equivalent of having 2.8 times the amplifier
power! It had a modelled -3dB point
of about 42Hz, but as is the characteristic of such band-pass designs, fell
away quickly at the top end, being 3dB
down at 110Hz. This concerned me,
as many small outdoor speakers will
struggle to get down to 110Hz.
The ported enclosure had a -3dB
point of 36Hz (substantially better
than the other designs), and was nearly
3dB up at 110Hz. It peaked at about
65Hz (over 6dB up) and had a greater
‘area under the curve’ than the other
two designs. It was modelled using
a 100mm-long, 50mm inner diameter port.
Note that I was not aiming for a flat
response – since the sub can be used
outside, it needs as much gain as possible without becoming crazily peaky.
This modelling was just a starting
point – it’s easy to look at lines on a
PC screen and think that they represent reality, not just a model of reality. However, software modelling is a
good way of getting into the region of
what is wanted.
What counts as a subwoofer?
A traditional subwoofer works only at very low frequencies – for example,
below 40Hz. That is, the subwoofer provides output below the frequencies of
a conventional woofer. However, over time, this definition has become blurred.
Computer sound systems, for example, typically use two small satellite
speakers that might work down to only 200Hz, with the separate ‘subwoofer’
providing the frequencies below this. Many high-level and custom car sound
systems use a subwoofer, but again, it typically provides the bass component
below 100-200Hz.
So rather than developing only very low frequencies, a subwoofer has come
to be known as any separate speaker that provides the bass.
If you’re listening to music, how low a frequency response is actually
required? The response of human hearing is stated as being 20-20,000Hz.
However, age reduces this range, and 20Hz can arguably be more clearly felt
as vibrations than heard.
A pipe organ can produce notes at just 16Hz, but few pipe organ recordings
have this low frequency content. There’s not much point in including sounds that
no speakers will reproduce! A bass guitar and a double bass go down to 41Hz,
which is clearly audible. A bass drum can produce frequencies of 20-120Hz,
usually centred around 40Hz. The lowest note on a standard piano is 27.5Hz.
So, while having as low a frequency response as possible is desirable, in
the real world, a speaker system that can reproduce down to 40Hz will give
the vast majority of what is needed. Whether you then call that speaker a subwoofer is up to you!
This subwoofer is not designed to fill large outside areas with booming bass.
To do so, it would need to be about ten times as big, ten times as expensive
and ten times as powerful! Instead, it’s designed to add bottom-end and body to
normal background music played at quiet-to-moderate levels in outdoor areas.
Fig.1: the model outputs (predicted frequency responses) for three different
enclosure designs: sealed (blue), band-pass (red) and ported (green). The
ported design was chosen.
Table 1 – WS 17 E 8Ω specifications
Specification Listed
Speaker A
Speaker B
Used in modelling
DC resistance 6.3W
6.1W
6.2W
–
Sensitivity <at> 1W/1m 88dB
85dB
85db
–
Resonant frequency 41Hz
45Hz
43Hz
44Hz
Qms 2.83
3.45
3.22
3.4
Isobaric configuration
Qes 0.81
1.10
1.01
1.1
The two drivers are mounted in
an isobaric configuration – that is,
Qts 0.63
0.83
0.77
0.8
Vas 31L
25L
27L
26L
siliconchip.com.au
Australia's electronics magazine
June 2025 75
Photo 1: the Bunnings fibre
cement stool. Making it into a
subwoofer doesn’t change its
appearance much – it will
just have a slightly larger
gap at its base.
Source: Bunnings
Photo 2:
this halogen
incandescent
light bulb
is used as
the speaker
protector. Its
resistance
rapidly
rises
as the
current
flow through
it increases,
limiting the
maximum
speaker power.
Source: Narva
face-to-face with a small, trapped air
volume between them. The drivers
are wired out of phase so that as one
pushes, the other pulls.
The advantage of an isobaric configuration is that the drivers act as if
they are working in a larger enclosure
volume, and most importantly from
our perspective, the power handling
of the drivers doubles from a nominal 60W (90W peak) to 120W (180W
peak).
The use of paralleled drivers
explains the need for selecting 8W
designs – the two drivers then form
a nominally 4W amplifier load. The
WinISD software can model isobaric
configurations.
Test and development
To initially test the design, a disc
of 22mm-thick weatherproof particleboard was cut so that it would
sit within the upturned stool, about
130mm down from the end. This
placement gives room for the drivers
and the port to project from both sides
of the baffle.
Two holes were cut in the particleboard disc – one for the drivers and the
other for the port. The hole for the port
was made a tight fit so that different
lengths of 50mm ID PVC plastic pipe
could be trialled. The gap between the
edge of the particleboard disc and the
inner wall of the stool was temporarily sealed.
A layer of polyester quilt wadding
76
Silicon Chip
was placed inside the enclosure, with
care taken that it did not block the port.
The wadding prevents sound reflections off the hard interior surfaces.
The subwoofer stool could then be
tested upside-down. A frequency generator app (Signal Gen from Media
Punk Studios) on an iPhone was used
in conjunction with an audio amplifier to test the subwoofer on sine wave
sweeps from 150Hz down to 25Hz.
Always test at low volumes – you
can easily blow up drivers with sinewave testing!
Different port lengths were trialled,
with a 190mm-long port giving better
results to my ears than the modelled
100mm port. Yes, that’s a big difference, implying the enclosure tuning
point has moved from about 47Hz
down to about 35Hz. Testing of the
completed enclosure showed an actual
enclosure tuned frequency of 38Hz.
Using shorter ports than 100mm
gave a much peakier response – something the software modelling had
shown would be the case. For example,
using a 50mm ID port that was only
40mm long gave a modelled +10.5dB
peak at about 75Hz. Therefore, if
you’re not unduly concerned about
one-note bass and just want it louder,
use a shorter port like this.
Extensive testing with music followed, and this showed something
else. Because these are not expensive
drivers with huge cone travel, driving the sub hard could bottom-out the
drivers’ suspensions. This is important
to understand, because many people
Speaker resonance and one-note bass
Many people confuse a good bass response with a pronounced bass resonance. I remember when I was young and trying to make my car sound system
perform well. I’d fitted a new amplifier, new speakers and a new head unit (a
cassette player in those days!). In one particular song, a note from the bass
guitar caused the whole car to vibrate… something I thought was really cool.
What was happening was that a major speaker resonance was being triggered, and that excited the car. Nowadays, I’d see that as a shortcoming!
A speaker resonance is where, for a given power input, the audio output
of the speaker sharply peaks. That is, at a particular frequency, the speaker
is much more efficient at turning electrical input power into an audio output.
The problem with a subwoofer having a pronounced resonance is that the
output at that frequency will dominate the rest of the content. This is often
termed ‘one-note bass’. One-note bass is the thump, thump you often hear in
poor sound systems – all the bass, no matter its actual frequency, is reproduced as much the same-sounding thump.
Australia's electronics magazine
siliconchip.com.au
Photo 3: the underside view
of the baffle with the
speakers, port, protection
light bulb and terminal
strip temporarily
mounted. In the
final design, some
of the parts were
orientated slightly
differently.
Photo 4: a closeup showing the
8mm flanged
nuts used as
spacers between
the speaker
mounting lugs,
the protection
light bulb
mounted on its
bracket and the
terminal strip.
over-drive subs without realising that
they are doing so.
When developing a subwoofer,
always test it with a crossover and
without the other speakers running.
That is, listen to just the sub working
at only low frequencies. This way,
you can hear what is really happening, without the sound being masked
by the other speakers.
the speaker system, they will dominate the sound.
For example, without a sub crossover, the lower midrange can be
over-emphasised. Crossovers can be
achieved by using a series inductor
in the subwoofer speaker feed (not so
good), or much better, using an electronic low-pass or band-pass filter.
Subwoofer crossovers
Two solutions were developed
to prevent the sub from being overdriven. The first was to temporarily place a heavy lid on top of the
upturned sub, raised from the stool
body by 10mm spacers. This replicates how the sub will actually be used
– inverted and placed on the ground
on short feet.
The use of this lid (or in use, the
presence of the ground) better acoustically loads the drivers, reducing
their displacement peaks. Technically,
we’re also adding another chamber
and port (the gap around the periphery), but that made little difference
to the sound except that upper frequencies were better suppressed. You
don’t want these coming out of a sub
anyway.
The other solution was electronic –
or at least, electric. Many professional
speakers used in commercial settings
have a very simple approach to protecting (especially) the tweeters. They
place a normal incandescent light bulb
in series with the drive to the speaker.
A subwoofer – especially a small
one like this – must be ‘crossed over’.
It must not be fed frequencies outside the range of those you’re trying to
reproduce. The reason for this is that a
small sub can easily reproduce higher
frequencies, and if you have the sub
producing them as well as the rest of
Photo 5: two of these Visaton 170mm
(6.5in) drivers are used in the
subwoofer, mounted in an isobaric
configuration. Source: Visaton
siliconchip.com.au
Speaker protection
Australia's electronics magazine
Low-voltage incandescent light
bulbs have low resistance (eg, 0.7W)
when they are cold but about 15 times
as much resistance when they are hot
– that is, when the filament is glowing brightly.
Therefore, as the current flowing
through the bulb increases, so does its
resistance, limiting the power getting
to the protected speaker. We decided
to take a similar approach to protect
the subwoofer drivers.
Many different light bulbs were
tested, including those with different
voltages and wattages, and multiple
bulbs wired in series, parallel and
series/parallel configurations. The aim
was to limit power to the subwoofer
such that the speakers could not be
overdriven on a variety of music. However, a lot depends on the amplifier you
are using, the type of music you play
– and how loudly you play it!
While the light bulb approach has
audio downsides (it is a non-linear
compressor), and so is frowned on
by purists, it works very effectively.
Depending on the music type and
power level, the bulb may not glow at
all, glow just a little, or light brightly.
Furthermore, it has a short-term
memory in that if the power is repeatedly high (eg, you are loudly playing
a song with lots of bass), the filament
stays warm and so limits the power
earlier. To put this another way, if the
subwoofer is constantly being overdriven, the sub output drops a lot – it
June 2025 77
Light bulb based speaker power limiters
The question that is always asked by people wanting to use light bulbs as
speaker power limiters is how to choose the correct bulb for the application.
The bottom line is that it is nearly impossible to do it theoretically – testing is
the only practical way.
The difficulty with trying to specify the required light bulb theoretically is
that the resistance posed by the bulb constantly varies with filament temperature. In turn, this is governed by the light bulb’s characteristics, amplifier
power, the type of music being played and the impedance curve of the speaker
being protected.
If we were using a sinewave as the signal, it would all become much simpler – but we aren’t.
Even the bulb’s maximum continuous power dissipation (ie, the wattage
rating) isn’t as useful as it might first appear. In our application, the bulb is
required to dissipate large amounts of power only on very short transients.
Therefore, the power limiting that occurs depends in part on the response
speed of the filament.
Furthermore, the filament has a thermal memory. If it is dissipating large
amounts of power in successive bursts (eg, there is a rhythmic bass beat),
the filament stays hot between the bass notes. It therefore has a higher constant resistance and so the expected high pulses of amplifier power are not
fully developed!
Based on the voltage swings of the audio signal, it would appear obvious
that a bulb with a higher voltage rating (eg, 60V) should be used – however,
such a bulb has a higher cold resistance, so it will reduce amplifier output
power all the time. That is not what we want.
In the case of the project described here, the 24V 55W halogen bulb worked
well. A similar result could also be achieved using multiple 24V 18W tail-light
bulbs. However, they were more expensive to buy than the single 55W bulb.
It’s a fascinating area, and we’d love to hear about any successful results
readers have gained using light bulbs for speaker protection.
Two light
bulbs
used to
limit the
power in
a Bose
Lifestyle
speaker
system.
is actually louder when the amplifier
is turned back down.
By watching the filament lamp
during testing, you can also get a very
good idea of when the speaker is being
driven too hard and so reduce the maximum power the sub will ever see.
(More on setting up the amplifier later.)
If, in ‘normal’ use, some crazy dude
gets hold of the amplifier knob and
cranks it right up (eg, when you’re
away on holiday and the kids decide
to host a party!), the light bulb will
protect the speaker. If the worst comes
to the worst, the bulb will likely blow
before the drivers do, cutting off the
subwoofer output.
We have nominated using a single
Narva 24V 55W bulb (part number
48701). This bulb costs about $10 from
automotive parts shops. It is difficult
to over-drive the sub on normal music
with this bulb wired in series, using
any amplifier up to about 100W.
However, if you want to be less conservative, using two of these bulbs in
parallel gives more subwoofer power
but still some protection. Of course,
you can choose to delete the protection bulbs entirely and use only a lowpower amplifier. However, we suggest
using the single light bulb.
Despite the combined drivers being
rated at 180W peak, this does not mean
that if the sub is used with an amplifier
having less power than 180W, the sub
requires no protection. Remember, the
protection is primarily to protect the
drivers from being over-driven rather
than their voice coils being burned out.
Warning: if the subwoofer is continuously overdriven, the protection
lamp will become very hot. The subwoofer should always be placed on a
firm, level and non-combustible surface like tiles, concrete or similar. It
should not be placed on dry grass.
Construction
Construction is easy, and should
take you only about an hour, spread
over two days. The steps are:
1. Make the baffle and trial-fit the
speakers, port, protection lamp and
terminal strip to it.
2. Disassemble the baffle, removing
all the parts.
3. Glue the baffle, port and feet in
place and let the glue harden for 24
hours.
4. Fit and wire the speakers, protection lamp and terminal strip.
5. Test it.
78
Silicon Chip
Australia's electronics magazine
siliconchip.com.au
Photos 6 & 7: the baffle and port glued into place with Liquid Nails. The port
protrudes from both sides of the baffle, while the two drivers are positioned
face-to-face in the opening. The towel under the stool protects this surface when
working on the subwoofer. Once the glue has hardened, you can paint the inside
of the enclosure, the baffle and the port tube.
Photo 8: a close-up of the protection
lamp and terminal strip wiring. Note
the cable going through the baffle to
the other speaker.
The first step is to use a jigsaw to cut
a disc of particleboard about 285mm
in diameter. Measure the maximum
diameter of the opening in the stool’s
base – the disc should be just smaller
than this. The stools are handmade
and so vary a bit in size.
We used 22mm-thick, moisture-
resistant particleboard (a flooring
offcut), but if you seal it on all sides
with paint before gluing it into place,
slightly thinner MDF should be fine.
Don’t use material less than about
18mm thick – the peripheral glue
needs plenty of ‘meat’ to adhere to.
Cut a 165mm hole in the baffle for
the drivers to sit in, and mark and
drill small diameter pilot holes for
the particleboard screws that will
hold the drivers in place. Next, use
a hole saw to make the opening in
the baffle for the 50mm ID PVC pipe.
The required hole diameter is 56mm
– if you don’t have a hole saw of this
diameter, make a smaller hole and
then file it to size.
The exact location of these holes is
not critical – just ensure the speakers
and port clear the inner walls of the
stool. We recommend proper safety
precautions when cutting MDF, such
as using a respirator and cutting in a
well-ventilated location.
Drill a small hole for the inside
speaker’s cable to come through from
the other side of the baffle.
Cut a suitable speaker gasket from
a thin foam rubber sheet before dropping the first speaker into place. In the
final assembly, you can use silicone if
on the baseplate and enlarge this hole
to 3mm. Be very careful when drilling
these holes – it is easy to damage the
lamp (eg, by dropping it).
The lamp mounts on a small
right-angle bracket that is attached to
the baffle with a wood screw. Wiring
connections to the lamp are by two
solder lugs that are attached with the
3mm screws.
Ensure the baffle assembly will
fit inside the stool without the port
fouling the inside wall. When you
are happy that everything will fit correctly, remove the baffle and disassemble it. If using non-weatherproof MDF,
paint the baffle on both sides and on
all cut edges.
Spread ‘water clean-up’ Liquid
Nails (or equivalent) building adhesive at an appropriate height around
the inside of the stool where the baffle
will sit. Be generous with this glue –
you want no leaks and for the baffle
siliconchip.com.au
you don’t want to make a gasket. The
other speaker fits on top, so they mount
face-to-face (see Fig.2).
These speakers have an external
gasket, so they seal to each other very
well – no further gasket or sealant is
needed between them.
Use 6mm spacers between the two
sets of speaker mounting holes so
that the speakers are clamped firmly
together, but the mounting tags are
not overly bent. I used 8mm flanged
nuts that had the required 6mm depth.
The particleboard screws go through
both sets of speaker mounting tags and
the spacers, holding the two speakers
firmly to the baffle.
Push the 190mm PVC pipe through
the hole in the baffle; the pipe projects
about equally from each side.
Next, mount the protective light
bulb. To do this, enlarge the existing
hole in the bulb’s bottom tang to 3mm.
Nip off one of the nipple protrusions
Fig.2: the two drivers are
mounted face-to-face, being
inserted into the baffle from
the underside of the enclosure.
Australia's electronics magazine
June 2025 79
to be held in place very firmly. Ensure
the glue is the water clean-up type or it
will be difficult to remove the excess!
(We suggest “Liquid Nails Fast Grab”,
Bunnings I/N 1230096).
Carefully drop the bare baffle into
place and push it down onto the glue,
ensuring the baffle stays level. Apply
more glue around the gap between the
baffle and the inside of the stool and
smooth the glue with a wet finger, wiping up any excess with a wet cloth that
you repeatedly rinse in water. Insert
the vent, also sealing it into place with
the glue.
Let the glue harden for at least 24
hours. You may choose to paint the
interior of the stool at this stage –
ie, the baffle, glue and visible inside
wall of the stool. I did so using black
spray paint.
A single layer of quilt wadding,
about 500 × 500mm can now be glued
in the bottom of the enclosure (the
top when it is orientated normally).
This step is optional – I am not sure
it makes a great deal of difference, but
it will possibly reduce ‘hollow sounding’ reflections.
Place the gasket on the underside of
the first speaker or, if not using a gasket, apply silicone around the upper
edge of the hole.
Solder the speaker’s connecting
cable to its terminals, then feed this
wire through the baffle hole, pushing
it from the inside by placing your hand
through the speaker hole.
Ensure you know the polarity of your
connections, eg, by using coloured
wires or a cable with a trace on one
conductor.
Put the first speaker into place and
then mount the second speaker on top,
remembering to include the spacers.
Insert the four screws and tighten in a
series of steps using a diagonal tightening pattern.
Wire the two speakers out of phase
– the inside speaker’s positive connection goes to the outside speaker’s negative and vice versa (see Fig.3). Seal
the wiring hole in the baffle.
Next, install the protective light
bulb. It mounts on a small bracket that
is attached to the baffle with a particleboard screw (drill small diameter pilot
holes for the screw). Do not place the
lamp against the PVC vent.
If you have touched the bulb’s glass
at any point in the installation process,
wipe it with a cloth moistened in methylated spirits. This removes any oils
that may have been deposited on the
glass from your fingers, which could
potentially weaken the glass.
The terminal strip mounts next,
again with a particleboard screw into
a pilot hole. Wire the drivers to the
terminal strip with the light bulb in
series (it doesn’t matter which lead
it goes in).
Because the outside driver pushes
air outwards when the cone moves
backwards (rather than the normal
forwards), the negative terminal of the
outer driver connects to the positive
speaker connection terminal. Mark
this with a (+).
Should the vent be flared?
The vent uses straight rather than
flared ends. Flared ends reduce port
noise (sometimes called ‘chuffing’).
However, considering the size of the
drivers and their isobaric configuration, a large diameter vent has been
used, so air velocities in the port are
relatively low. No port noise could be
heard even without flares.
Photo 9: testing the subwoofer with Niles wall-mounted speakers on a deck under construction. The ceiling is 2.7m high,
and the deck area is about 10 × 5m. On a deck this large, two subwoofers spaced about 5m apart will give the best results.
80
Silicon Chip
Australia's electronics magazine
siliconchip.com.au
Testing
The next step is to test the subwoofer. Place it upright on its feet on
a firm, flat surface. Feed the subwoofer
through an amplifier and crossover,
and ensure other speakers cannot
be heard. Use a frequency generator
app to perform a sweep from 200Hz
down to 20Hz. The speaker should
be audible down to about 35Hz, and
there should be no buzzes, whistles
or rattles.
If there are, isolate where the sound
is coming from (eg, a loose port or leak
around the frames of the drivers) and
then fix the problem. If you hear a
buzz, ensure it’s not something in the
room becoming excited, rather than
the subwoofer itself.
If the bass output is poor, check the
speaker phasing, ensuring the speakers are wired out of phase.
Now switch to the type of music
you normally play. Do not run any
high-power tests with the frequency
generator. Ensure you can see if the
light bulb is glowing brightly – eg, in
dim conditions, it will cast a visible
ring of light around the open base of
the enclosure. Increase the amplifier
gain until the filament is just glowing
on bassy passages.
Now, while not changing the amplifier gain, select music of the type that
has as much bass as you will ever listen to. The light bulb(s) should light
quite brightly on these greater bass
passages, showing the protection is
working, and the drivers should not
bottom out.
If the bulb is glowing brightly a lot
of the time, the amplifier gain is too
Fig.3: wire the two speakers out of
phase so that as one pushes, the other
pulls (and vice versa). The protection
light bulb is inserted in one conductor
of the main feed (either is OK).
siliconchip.com.au
Parts List – Outdoor Subwoofer
2 Visaton WS 17 E 8W speakers [RS Components 431-8563;
there are many other suppliers]
1 Marquee Sorrento 350 × 350 × 450mm Side Stool [Bunnings I/N 0596376]
1 300 × 300mm 22mm-thick weatherproof particleboard sheet
1 190mm length of 50mm internal diameter PVC DWV pipe
4 25mm diameter, 10mm thick white rubber feet
1 cartridge of water clean-up Liquid Nails [Bunnings I/N 1230096]
1 Narva 48701 24V 55W automotive light bulb [Car parts supplier]
1 500 × 500mm section of dressmaker’s quilt wadding [Spotlight]
1 small terminal strip (eg, 2-way)
1 packet of self-tapping particleboard screws
various lengths of wire & cable
assorted small hardware items (screws, washers, nuts etc)
4 6mm spacers (particleboard screws must fit through)
1 thin foam rubber sheet
1 small steel right-angle bracket
high. Of course, depending on the
amplifier power, you may not see the
bulb light at all.
Results
The prototype speaker had good
output from 35Hz to 200Hz. Furthermore, the response was pleasingly
smooth across this range. The measured impedance did not drop below
4W at any point in the frequency range.
Using the specified protection lamp,
amplifier powers up to 100W should
be fine when playing normal program
material.
Setup
Remember that the subwoofer needs
its own amplifier, and that amplifier needs either a built-in subwoofer
crossover or to be fed only low frequencies via an electronic crossover. Lowcost Class-D subwoofer amplifiers with
built-in crossovers are readily available, but it can be much cheaper to use
a surplus, bridgeable stereo amplifier
with an adjustable subwoofer crossover on its input.
The location of the subwoofer is
important. Placing the subwoofer at
the intersection of a wall and the floor
causes greater loading of the speaker’s
drivers. As a result, the energy of the
speaker is better communicated to the
air, so the bass output will increase.
Placing the sub at the intersection of
two walls and the floor increases this
effect even more.
Conversely, placing the sub on a
pedestal in the middle of the room or
outdoor area will reduce the output.
Large changes in output are achievable
by these various placements.
Australia's electronics magazine
The other aspect of placement is that
when used outside, the closer the sub
is to you, the more its presence will be
felt. Unlike in a small room, where the
loudness of the sub doesn’t vary much
wherever you are in the room, outside
the low frequencies are clearly louder
when you are closer to the sub. Therefore, place it near where you will most
often be sitting.
When placed on the floor against a
wall, the sub was effective over about
a 25m2 area – it works fine in an open
area about 5 × 5m. If your deck or patio
area is larger than this, you could use
two of these subs.
To limit cone movement, the open
end of the sub should always be
placed on the ground (spaced upwards
by its feet). If the sub is to be used
upside-down with the opening facing upwards, a heavy panel should be
placed over the opening, again spaced
upwards by about 10mm.
The sub is weatherproof in that
the concrete stool can cope with rain
or being sprayed with a hose. However, the sub is open underneath, so it
should not be placed on grass or any
other surface where there is moisture
present all the time. If washing a deck
or other outside area where the sub is
placed, move it first.
You may occasionally wish to spray
some insecticide into the interior of
the enclosure (including through the
port) to prevent bugs and spiders making colonies.
Finally, if you can obviously hear
that the sub is working, it’s probably too loud – it should be just part
of the music, not a separate, identifiable entity.
SC
June 2025 81
|