This is only a preview of the July 2025 issue of Silicon Chip. You can view 37 of the 104 pages in the full issue, including the advertisments. For full access, purchase the issue for $10.00 or subscribe for access to the latest issues. Articles in this series:
Articles in this series:
Items relevant to "The SmartProbe":
Articles in this series:
Items relevant to "Hot Water System Solar Diverter, part two":
Items relevant to "Low-cost electronic modules: 8×16 LED Matrix module":
Items relevant to "SSB Shortwave Receiver, part 2":
Purchase a printed copy of this issue for $13.00. |
Vintage Radio
The Eddystone EC10 Mk2
All Transistor Shortwave Radio
This all band set was UK-based Eddystone’s first release of an alltransistor receiver in 1973. It’s a good performer if noisy at full gain. It
has a switchable AGC, a BFO, a bandpass filter and a fine-tuning knob.
Its biggest weakness is non-linear tuning.
By Ian Batty
Y
ou may recall that Sony began
with a rice cooker and National/
Matsushita with a bicycle lamp. However, Stratton and Company (who
would become Eddystone) began
in 1860 making much more modest
goods: steel pins and hairpins.
Stratton expanded into gentlemen’s
jewellery, ladies’ compacts, a variety
of small metal products – including
knitting needles, thimbles, hat pins
and crochet hooks – and a whole range
of do-it-yourself kits for making model
ships and aeroplanes, pearl flowers,
seagrass stools and timber bead mats.
Changes in fashion saw the demand
for hairpins slump in the early 1920s.
Needing new products to survive, manager George Laughton’s son (a radio
enthusiast) asked a simple question:
“Why not make wireless components?”
88
Silicon Chip
It was 1923 and the die was cast.
Needing a trade name, what could be
better to project an aura of reliability and prominence than that of the
world’s first open ocean lighthouse,
the Eddystone Light? First operational
in 1699, it had given over 200 years of
faithful, life-saving service by 1923.
Listeners in 1927 must have been
fascinated by Eddystone’s first shortwave receiver. They could see the parts
moving and the valves light up through
a glass panel.
Eddystone expanded, becoming a
world-famous leader in communications equipment. You’ll find their
products, especially receivers, in collections around the world. I reckon
that any collection lacking an Eddystone is ‘yet to be completed’.
The year 1973 was Eddystone’s
Australia's electronics magazine
50th anniversary, and valve-equipped
receivers were being phased out. It
was not due to a lack of demand but
because obtaining many of the components was no longer possible.
The EC10, Eddystone’s first all-
transistor receiver, looks the goods.
It has a large, easy-to-read dial, the
famous flywheel-equipped tuning
mechanism and a compact size. But
don’t be fooled by that size – it competes well with its valve-equipped predecessors, but with the convenience of
hundreds of hours of operation using
internal batteries.
Description
The EC10 is a general-coverage,
single-conversion superhet that operates from batteries or a plug-in mains
supply that replaces the battery
siliconchip.com.au
The rear of the EC10 has the antenna socket on the left (three
to allow for a wire antenna or telescopic rod) and both high and low impedance audio outputs on the right.
compartment. It uses ten transistors:
five alloy-diffused high-frequency
types in the tuner/IF section and five
alloyed-junction types in the audio
section, all PNP.
Its coverage is 550kHz to 30MHz and
intermediate frequency (IF) is 465kHz:
• Band 1 is 18MHz to 30MHz.
• Band 2 is 8.5MHz to 18MHz.
• Band 3 is 3.5MHz to 8.5MHz
• Band 4 is 1.5MHz to 3.5MHz.
• Band 5 is 550kHz to 1.5MHz.
The Mark I uses three diodes, while
the Mark II adds three, for a total of
six. It features a signal strength meter,
which is helpful when tuning. The
Fine Tuning control, which operates
a variable-capacitance diode (varicap)
in the local oscillator (LO) section, is
essential when tuning signals in the
highest band.
All models feature an RF gain control and a beat frequency oscillator
(BFO) for use with CW or SSB signals.
There is also a switchable audio filter
centred on 1kHz to improve the clarity of CW signals. The audio output
is quoted as 800mW into the internal
speaker. An external speaker can be
used, and there is a high-impedance
audio output for connection to an
external audio amplifier.
The set can operate with various
antennas: unbalanced, balanced or a
short telescopic rod. Its input impedance is 75W on Bands 1 through 4 and
400W on Band 5. Sensitivity is quoted
siliconchip.com.au
as better than 5μV on Bands 2-5 and
better than 15μV on Band 1.
The EC10’s only limitation is the
failure to use a straight-line frequency
tuning capacitor, so the frequency divisions are compressed towards the top
end of each band.
Construction
The set is well-built, with the traditional ‘flywheel’ on the tuning knob.
This allows the highly-geared tuning
system to spin rapidly from end to end
across the selected band.
The chassis and front panel withdraw easily from the case and the
internal construction is sound. Most
electronic components are mounted
on two printed circuit boards: one for
the tuner (RF) and the other for IF/
audio. The IF/audio board is mounted
copper-side on top, so measurements
are easily made.
Unfortunately, two of the IF transformers use double slugs, and the service notes describe the relocation of
the IF/audio board to allow access to
the inside slugs for a complete alignment and other work.
Circuit description
I could not find a completely legible circuit diagram online, so I have
redrawn Eddystone’s original for clarity and ease of description, including the power supply circuit from
my EC10 MKII. I have moved some
Australia's electronics magazine
components from their original locations but retained Eddystone’s numbering – see Fig.1 overleaf.
I have added DC circuit voltages to
the diagram, with signal voltages in
two tables at the right of the drawing.
Note that the band change switch
sections (S1a to S1j) are all shown
with Band 2 selected and viewed
from the rear. Band 1 is, thus, fully
anti-clockwise, while Band 5 is fully
clockwise.
Eddystone showed each section
from its contact side. I found this confusing, as some sections have their
contact sets on towards the front of
the set and others to the rear. This
demanded that one visualise some
sections rotating clockwise and others anti-clockwise.
The EC10 uses a grounded-base RF
amplifier. We’re probably familiar with
common-base’s low input impedance,
typically in the low tens of ohms, and
its current gain of just under unity.
For these reasons, voltage amplifier
designs adopted the common-emitter
configuration, with its much higher
input impedance and current gain.
However, the common-base configuration has a very high output impedance, in the hundreds of kilohms at
audio frequencies. As noted in the
article on General Electric’s P-807
5-
t ransistor set (November 2015
issue; siliconchip.au/Article/9405),
common-base’s power gain – due to its
July 2025 89
high output impedance – can approach
that of common-emitter.
Common-base’s low feedback capacitance also makes it more suited to
operation at higher frequencies than
common emitter, even in wideband
amplifiers such as video output stages
in CRT-based televisions. Common-
base’s low input impedance is easily
matched in RF circuits by tapping the
90
Silicon Chip
driving tuned circuit or matching coil.
Common-base’s high output impedance minimises loading of the EC10’s
selected RF transformer (L7~L11) primary, thus realising the maximum Q
for each primary tuned circuit.
Local oscillator TR3 also operates
in grounded-base configuration. While
the OC171 can, in theory, work easily to the top end of the HF band in
Australia's electronics magazine
common-emitter, using common-base
ensures more constant output as the
set is tuned to 30MHz.
Tuner section
All trimmers are 6-25pF types, while
all transistors in the tuner and IF sections are alloy-diffused OC171s in
four-lead metal TO7 cases.
Antenna selector S1a selects
siliconchip.com.au
Fig.1: my redrawn EC10
Mk2 circuit diagram.
transformers L2 (Band 1) to L6 (Band
5). Bandstop filter L1/C2 is added in
series on Band 5 to improve IF rejection. The input can be unbalanced
(A1 to ground, input to A2), balanced
(to A1 and A2), or a factory-supplied
telescopic rod to A3.
The RF stage is protected against
damaging overload by D4/D5, back-toback silicon diodes that limit the signal
siliconchip.com.au
at the selected antenna coil primary to
about 600mV peak-to-peak.
The antenna transformer secondaries are tuned by the tuning gang’s
antenna section, C15. Bands 5 and 4
use the full capacitance sweep of C15,
while Bands 3, 2, and 1 are restricted
by band spread capacitors (C8/C9/
C10). Band 1’s range (around 1:1.7) is
further limited by 390pF padder C11.
Australia's electronics magazine
All transformers in the front end are
slug-tuned for low-end alignment and
trimmer-tuned for high-end alignment.
S1b connects the selected antenna
transformer secondary to the tuning
gang’s antenna section, C15. A selector
ring on S1b shorts the unused antenna
transformers’ secondaries, eliminating
the possibility of absorption and dead
spots in tuning.
July 2025 91
Shock hazards
I have found English-manufactured equipment to generally have dangerous mains wiring. The EC10 has a plug-in power supply, with four-pole plug PL1 connecting the supply
to the main chassis. Two wires carry the 9V DC supply, and the other two carry mains
to the on/off switch in the RF gain control.
The wiring is lightweight gauge, and its connections to the plug are not insulated. I
can vouch for this, having found out by almost throwing the set off the bench in reaction to a nasty mains shock! Similarly, the connections to the back of the switch in the
RF Gain control are not insulated.
Two yellow paper dots should remind the user how to connect the plug if they have
not fallen off. Although the plug is mechanically polarised, it may be possible to insert
it backwards, reversing the -9V DC polarity and potentially destroying the set. Additionally, the power supply’s mains lead simply passed through a grommet with no cord
anchor/clamp.
I rectified the first hazard by disconnecting the leads to PL1, sliding heatshrink tubing
over each lead, then reconnecting and shrinking the tubing to prevent any possibility of
contact with the live terminals. I also fitted a cord anchor to securely retain the power
supply’s mains lead. I strongly recommend that you examine any equipment – of any
origin, but especially English – for safety and proper insulation of mains connections.
Left: two of the tabs on
PL1 carry mains and are
not insulated from the
factory.
Below: the rest of the
power supply section.
The selected transformer secondary
connects, via S1c, to the emitter of RF
amplifier transistor TR1. This has AGC
applied to its base, which is bypassed
to RF ground.
TR1’s collector connects to the primary of the selected RF transformer
(L7~L11) via S1d. As with S1c, this
includes a shorting ring. L7/L8 are also
band spread via C20/C26. The selected
transformer connects to the RF section
of the tuning gang (C27) via S1e. Like
Band 1 antenna transformer L2, Band
1’s RF transformer, L7, has a 390pF
padding capacitor, C19.
The selected RF transformer’s secondary is connected to the base of converter transistor TR2 via S1f. The local
oscillator signal is supplied to TR2’s
emitter from the selected LO transformer (L12~L16) via S1h. Capacitor
C19 reduces the LO signal’s injection
level on Band 1.
The LO must track at 465kHz
above the incoming signal, so it uses
92
Silicon Chip
a combination of the usual padding
and band spreading. Bands 5, 4 and
3 use the usual padding capacitors in
series with the gang.
Band 5’s padder capacitor C38
(500pF) seems about right for the
broadcast band, but capacitor C37
for Band 4 is a non-standard value
of 1.4nF. Band 3 uses another non-
standard value of 7nf (C46).
The increasing values of these padder capacitors means that they force
progressively less padding effect as the
LO’s frequency span rises from Band 5
(most effect) to Band 3 (least).
For Band 2 (8.5~18MHz), a 465kHz
offset between the LO and signal frequencies is negligible, so C45 (47nF)
is not for padding. It’s simply there to
block the LO’s DC collector voltage,
which would otherwise be shorted to
ground via the unselected LO primary/
tuned coils in the L12 to L16 coil set.
Band 1 is spread by 400pF capacitor
C44 to hold the LO to a restricted span
Australia's electronics magazine
(around 1:1.7), so it tracks with Band
1’s antenna and RF transformers. The
LO frequency span is restricted by C44
(400pF), but without the IF offset we’re
accustomed to in broadcast superhets.
The MKII’s fine tuning is provided
via varicap diode D6. This is most
effective on the higher bands. The
tuner section is fed from a stabilised
-4.5V supply, derived from the main
supply via zener diode D3 on the IF/
AF board. This reduces tuning drift
due to mains variations or battery ageing. Drift figures are quoted at better
than one part in 104 (<0.01%) per °C.
Converter transistor TR2 feeds the
IF signal via a shielded cable to the
primary of first IF transformer IFT1
on the IF-AF board.
IF section
Both IF amplifier transistors (TR4/
TR5) are OC171s. These alloy-diffused
types exhibit low feedback capacitances of around 2pF, so they operate without neutralisation. TR4 has
AGC applied, while TR5 works with
fixed bias.
TR4’s supply is decoupled by 1.5kW
resistor R24. The voltage drop across
this resistor reverse-biases AGC extension diode D1. Its anode, connected to a
tap on first IF transformer IFT1, is held
close to the supply voltage via the converter’s 100W decoupling resistor R18.
As the AGC begins to control TR4,
its collector current falls, reducing
the voltage drop across R24. Strong
signals will bring D1 into conduction and dampen the signal at IFT1’s
primary. This means the EC10 has
three gain-controlled elements: the
converter, the first IF amplifier and
the extension diode, giving a near-
constant output over a wide range of
signal levels.
IF transformers IFT1 and IFT2 both
have tuned, tapped primaries and secondaries. Final transformer IFT3 uses a
tuned, tapped primary, but an untuned
secondary to feed the low impedance
of demodulator diode D2.
The demodulator feeds audio to the
low-level audio output and, via the
volume control, to the audio section.
The DC voltage across the volume control also drives the 100µA Carrier Level
meter via multiplier resistor R48a.
The demodulator’s output supplies
the AGC line via R28, with the audio
signal filtered out by C63.
AGC is useful when receiving
amplitude-
modulated signals but is
siliconchip.com.au
not effective when receiving CW/
MCW (‘Morse’) or single-sideband
(SSB) signals. So the AGC can be deactivated by S2. This switch cuts off the
AGC voltage and biases the AGC line
to a fixed value via R22, while also
reducing the sensitivity of the Carrier
Level meter via R49a.
The AGC line is also affected by RF
Gain control RV1. This is in series with
the bias divider for TR4 (R20/R21),
allowing the lower part of the divider
to increase in resistance. This means
that the ‘top’ end of R21, which connects directly to the AGC line, will
become more negative as the gain control takes effect. The maximum gain
reduction is about 30dB. RV1’s effect
is augmented by the action of AGC
extension diode D1.
With no carrier, SSB signals cannot
be resolved unless one is reinserted at
demodulation. TR6, the beat frequency
oscillator (BFO), generates a 465kHz
signal that is fed back, via 1pF capacitor C67, to the collector of first IF transistor TR4.
The BFO frequency is variable, via
BFO Tune capacitor C70, to allow
the exact adjustment needed to produce speech from an SSB transmission, rather than ‘duck talk’. Adjusting the BFO to produce a 1kHz tone is
helpful when receiving weak CW signals and takes advantage of the 1kHz
audio filter’s narrow passband when
activated.
The set can be muted using the
Standby switch, which removes bias
from the RF amp and the first IF amp
by shorting the AGC line to ground.
It’s a two-pole switch, with its second
section available for custom wiring to
control external equipment.
allowing headphone-only operation.
The output stage works with fixed bias,
lacking the temperature compensation
that was common in domestic receivers of the day.
Power supply
Power is supplied either from a
plug-in battery pack containing six D
cells, which were available virtually
Audio section
everywhere at the time, via 12V or
In regular operation, the first audio 24V adaptors, or (for my set) a plug-in
stage transistor TR7 (an OC81) acts as 110/240V mains supply.
a simple preamplifier with load resisThe set connects to the power suptor R40. When the Audio Filter is acti- ply via a four-core cable carrying the
vated, audio bandpass filter L18/C76 supply voltage and connections to the
is put in series with R40. The filter, Operations switch S6, part of the RF
tuned to 1kHz, gives a very narrow gain control, which selects between
audio passband, greatly increasing a mains or battery power.
1kHz tone above the background noise.
Be aware that the plug on the set side
As noted earlier, setting the BFO is not insulated, leaving two exposed
for a 1kHz tone allows the resolution metal connections at mains potential.
of weak CW signals in the presence See the panel on shock hazards!
of atmospheric noise or other interThe mains power supply uses a
ference.
transformer, selenium bridge rectifier
TR7’s output goes to audio driver and pi filtering. The output voltage is
transistor TR8. This feeds phase- held to -9V by shunt rectifier diode
splitter transformer T1, which in turn D101. I found that this failed to regufeeds the two output transistors, TR9 late with low mains voltages, around
and TR10, both OC83s. They form the 220V, as shown by the dial lights flickpush-pull Class-B output stage, deliv- ering on strong audio output.
ering audio to the speaker via output
The internal dial lights are switched
transformer T2.
by the momentary Dial Lights pushbutThe EC10 has a Phones socket that ton S5, allowing power conservation
disconnects the internal speaker, during battery operation.
The top view of the Eddystone EC10 radio with its cover removed. The resistor and
capacitor added on this side of the board wire likely added at the factory as running changes.
History and repairs
I bought my EC10 at auction in Hawthorn back in the 1990s and it sat on
the shelf for some years. In the early
2000s, I moved to Harcourt, near Castlemaine and finally popped it onto
the test bench. On examination, it
was pretty well dead in the RF section, although there was noise from
the speaker.
Examination showed that the
antenna coil switch had suffered a
broken wafer. I desoldered all the connections, applied superglue to each
side, replaced it and rewired it. I was
able to get signals, but the sensitivity was still very poor. I aligned and
calibrated the RF stages, but the gain
was still low.
Loosening jammed slugs
The IF showed a ‘double hump’,
indicating severe misalignment. On
correctly aligning the IF, the gain came
up to the specified sensitivity of better
than 5μV on Bands 5 to 2 and better
than 15μV on Band 1.
There are two sizes of coil slugs in
the EC10: those in the RF section with
hexagonal centre holes, and those in
the IF transformers with continuous/
“through-hole” screwdriver slots. Be
aware that these need a special long
flat-bladed tool. Both types were either
loose or jammed. I carefully freed all
the jammed ones, but I wondered what
to do so I could adjust them to position
and not have them move.
I long ago gave up on wax, liquid
paper and nail polish, as I hope we all
1. Does the slug need alignment? You can save effort and time by using a ‘magic wand’,
a piece of heatshrink tubing maybe 10cm long with a slim ferrite slug in one end and a
brass slug in the other to find out before going any further.
Slide the ferrite end into the coil can. If the signal improves, the coil needs more inductance for correct alignment. If that makes things worse, try sliding the brass end into
the coil can. If the signal improves, the coil needs less inductance to align correctly. If
both slugs make things worse, the coil is correctly aligned.
2. Do not use spray lubricants. Most of these include organic oils that can actually jam
a slug in its thread.
3. If the slug has a screwdriver slot and the slot is damaged, trying to screw the slug out
of the coil towards you is the worst of all worlds. You are trying to drive the slug back
against the force of the screwdriver, and there may be slug debris in the threads! If the
coil has two slugs, try screwing the opposite slug right out of the coil.
Now that you have a (hopefully) untouched slot available on the inside of the jammed
slug, use that good slot to carefully screw the jammed slug into the centre and out the
end you are driving from. You can improve your chances by cleaning the coil former’s
available screw threads as thoroughly as you can before trying this. Some threads in
coil formers conform to Whitworth/SAE standards.
4. If you cannot get to the good end of the slug, try the ‘fridge move’. Put the set in the
fridge and leave it for a few hours. Differential contraction between the slug and the
former may loosen it once it all warms up.
I have also successfully used a variable-temperature hot air gun to cause differential expansion. Set it to around 70ºC. Warm the coil, occasionally withdrawing the gun
to feel how hot the coil or its can is. If you can leave a finger on the can for a second or
two, that’s good. Anything hotter risks melting or distorting plastic parts.
This method will likely soften any wax, grease or vanish, easing the job. I used this
method to recover an Emerson hybrid’s IF trannie that I had unwisely used WD-40 on.
5. If the slug has a hexagonal hole (TV IF strips, Eddystone EC10 type) or a slim slot
(‘Neosid’ type) going all the way through, it may be cracked into two or more parts along
its length. This is the worst of all possibilities, and you may need to replace the entire coil.
Destroying the slug and shaking the bits out may be possible, but you can do a lot of
damage to the coil l former. In the worst case, where you cannot get an exact replacement for the windings, you may be able to find a similar, good coil l former and can, warm
the coils, draw them off from the jammed former, and replace them onto the good spare.
6. If you get the slug out, thoroughly clean out the former’s threads with a tiny bottle
brush or compressed air (gently!). Do not use solvents, especially acetone, as they will
dissolve many plastics. Test with a good slug or a suitable thread tap. Once the thread
is clear, you’ll find that slugs/taps are often a little loose in a clean former.
7. When you replace the slug(s), use thin ‘plumber’s tape’ to stop the slugs from moving – it will hold them in place but will not gum up or jam.
have. My ‘magic ingredient’ is Teflon
plumber’s tape, which I also use in my
plumbing and irrigation work. With
the RF coils’ large threads, I found I
needed to fold a length of tape over
itself a few times to make the slugs fit
snugly. I used a single wrap of tape for
the finer-thread IF coils.
I used the set for a while, and two
subsequent faults appeared. First, the
BFO (needed for CW & SSB reception)
stopped working. The oscillator used
an OC171. This transistor had presumably succumbed to the dreaded
‘whiskers’, where minute dendrites
grow between the transistor element
and the grounded metal case within
the device and eventually stop it from
working.
Since the BFO operated at around
465kHz, the OC171 was considerably
under-rated. I had no spares, but an
OC400 (with a lower cutoff frequency)
worked just fine. I did need to adjust
the circuit capacitance to bring the
BFO back to the correct frequency, but
it calibrated up correctly.
The second fault appeared with
massive amounts of breakthrough of
the local FM band stations into the
broadcast band. I lived less than 10km
from Mount Alexander, which hosts
most of the FM radio and TV transmitters for the Central Highlands and
Goldfields.
On examination, a wire connecting to the broadcast (Band 5) antenna
coil had come adrift, open-circuiting
the tuning for this stage. Given the
amount of signal flooding in on the
FM band, it appears that the front
end was rectifying the FM signals
and allowing them to cross-modulate
into the IF.
The audio filter worked, but was
centred on about 800Hz and would
not adjust sufficiently. I replaced the
100nF tuning capacitor C76 with a
56nF type, and got the filter to its 1kHz
design frequency.
A curious thing
The alignment guide states that
injecting a signal at the input to the
IF strip needs only about 4μV to give
50mW audio output if the alignment
is correct. That implies the entire RF
section has near-unity gain. This mirrors the advice for an Eddystone VHF/
UHF set, the 770U, which I’d previously worked on.
It appears that Eddystone regards
the RF section as a ‘preselector’,
siliconchip.com.au
An underside view of the set. The EC10 uses 10 transistors and 18 inductors which you can see tightly packed into the
central section of the board. Note the speaker, which has a relatively rare rated impedance of 3W.
siliconchip.com.au
Australia's electronics magazine
July 2025 95
relying on the IF/AF sections to provide the majority of the gain.
Performance
For a first outing, it’s pretty good. I
was surprised that Eddystone did not
use a gang with straight-line frequency
plates. The result is that frequency
calibration is compressed towards the
top end of each band, as happened
with pocket transistor radios of the
day. Roger Lapthorne (G3XBM) noted
that the entire 10m band (28MHz to
29.7MHz) is only about 10mm wide
on the scale.
Pye Australia’s contemporary PHA
520, developed for the Colombo Plan,
did use a straight-line frequency cut,
making tuning much easier, especially
towards the top end of its 14.5~30MHz
band. The Fine Tuning control’s
authority varies, giving a range of some
±30kHz at 29MHz, but only around
±2.5kHz at 1400kHz.
The EC10 specification requires
50mW output, with a signal-plus-noise
to noise (S+N:N) ratio of 15dB from a
signal under 6µV on all bands. Table 1
shows my actual measurements.
Superhet receivers are prone to
image response interference, where a
signal that is twice the IF frequency
above (or below) the desired signal
will also be received. This is rarely a
problem with broadcast radios, where
the antenna tuned circuit can attenuate
the image by 60dB or more. A tuned RF
amplifier – by virtue of its tuned interstage circuit – will improve this figure.
At higher frequencies, image rejection is compromised as the bandwidth
of front-end tuned circuits widens.
The EC10 displayed such behaviour
– see Table 2.
At 600kHz, the -3dB bandwidth is
±2.2kHz, while at -60dB, it’s ±12.7kHz.
The audio bandwidth from the volume control to the speaker is 80Hz to
11kHz (-3dB). While that is impressive, the response from the antenna to
the speaker is only 60~1750Hz due to
the IF strip’s narrow bandwidth.
The audio filter, useful with CW/
MCW reception, has a -3dB bandwidth
of around ±50Hz at 1kHz. Audio output was around 400mW at clipping,
with 10% total harmonic distortion
(THD). At 50mW, THD was a low
1.8%, rising to 3% at 10mW, evidence
of crossover distortion at low levels.
Figs.2 & 3: the signal strength meter indication vs input signal level with
AGC on (left) and off (right).
Frequency Input signal level
Using three control stages, the AGC
gave a 12dB rise for a signal range of
90dB. Wow.
In use
For the first-generation unit that it
is, the EC10 works well. It is noisy at
full gain, with S+N:N ratios as low as
3dB. This implies that the equivalent
front-end noise is equal to the actual
signal level.
As noted with the Sony TR-712,
it’s possible to get a lot of gain with a
good amplifier design. Still, such an
approach is compromised by device
noise, for which germanium transistors are especially bad.
Additionally, the background noise
across the broadcast/HF bands, even
in areas well away from the ‘fog’ created by switchmode power supplies, is
commonly “some tens” of microvolts
per metre. Such a noise floor means
that the EC10’s useful performance
will, in practice, rival that of valveequipped competitors of the day.
At my location, on Victoria’s Mornington Peninsula, the broadcast band’s
residual noise level well exceeds
50μV/m!
This set, a Mark II, has a signal
strength meter, which measures the
demodulator’s DC output. With the
AGC on, it effectively measures the
AGC voltage, giving an essentially
logarithmic response. Due to the
AGC action, it provides a compressed
indication on signals of any strength,
showing a very broad tuning peak.
With the AGC off, the meter’s indication loosely tracks the input signal’s
strength, reaching the ‘8’ mark at about
35μV. Above that, the set overloads
and the signal becomes distorted, so
either the RF gain must be reduced or
the AGC switched in. For SSB reception, you would commonly have the
AGC off and use the RF gain control
to adjust the set’s gain.
Fig.2 shows that the signal strength
meter response is logarithmic with
AGC on, while Fig.3 demonstrates it’s
linear, with AGC off, up to the point
SC
of overload.
S+N:N
15dB input signal level
600kHz 2.0μV
6dB
6μV
1400kHz 0.3μV ♦
3dB
2.5μV
1.6MHz 1.2μV
3dB
4.5μV
3.5MHz 1.5μV ♦
3dB
5μV
3.8MHz 1.0μV
3dB
4μV
Frequency
Image rejection
8.0MHz 1.0μV
3dB
5μV
600kHz
64dB
9.0MHz 1.2μV
5dB
3.5μV
1.6MHz
53dB
17.5MHz 1.0μV
7dB
3μV
3.8MHz
58dB
18.5MHz 2.0μV
7dB
4μV
9.0MHz
36dB
29MHz 1.0μV
3dB
5μV
18.5MHz
16dB
Table 1 – sensitivity vs frequency ♦ gain was reduced to get a useful reading
Table 2 – freq vs image rejection
|